Best First Dance Songs That Still Aren’t Overplayed (Yet!

Because your love is one of a kind—your first dance should be too.

When it comes to first dances, there’s no denying the classics. We’ve all swayed to “Perfect” by Ed Sheeran or “At Last” by Etta James. And while those are beautiful songs, maybe you're looking for something a little different—a song that feels like it was written just for you and hasn’t been on every dance floor from here to eternity.

If you're searching for a first dance song that’s heartfelt, romantic, and still a bit under the radar, this list is for you. Here are some of the best first dance wedding songs that aren’t (yet) overplayed—and might just become your forever favorite.

🎶 1. “Beyond” – Leon Bridges

“I’m scared to death that she might be it / That the love is real, that the shoe might fit…”Smooth, soulful, and totally swoon-worthy. This one has timeless vibes and feels deeply personal.

🎶 2. “Lifetime” – Justin Bieber

“Some people come in your life for a reason / Others they come in your life for a season…”This lesser-known Bieber ballad is gentle and emotional—perfect for an intimate moment on the dance floor.

🎶 3. “You Are the Reason” (Duet Version) – Calum Scott & Leona Lewis

Stunning vocals, romantic lyrics, and just the right amount of drama. The duet version adds a beautiful depth to your first dance.

🎶 4. “Butterflies” – Kacey Musgraves

If you’re a couple who loves something sweet with a country-pop twist, this track brings whimsy, joy, and that “new love” feeling.

🎶 5. “Grow As We Go” – Ben Platt

For couples who’ve grown together or are starting a new journey side by side, this song hits all the right emotional notes without being too obvious.

🎶 6. “Tenerife Sea” – Ed Sheeran

Yes, it’s still Ed—but not the one everyone else chooses. “Tenerife Sea” is soft, poetic, and way less overused than “Perfect” or “Thinking Out Loud.”

🎶 7. “I Am Yours” – Andy Grammer

Feel-good lyrics and a tender melody make this an excellent choice for couples who want a mix of modern pop and sincere love.

🎶 8. “Say You Won’t Let Go” – James Arthur

This one flirts with the mainstream but still doesn’t show up at every wedding—and it tells a complete love story in just a few verses.

🎶 9. “If I Ain’t Got You” – Alicia Keys (Piano Acoustic Version)

Powerful, classy, and soulful. This stripped-down version adds intimacy while avoiding the played-out love song loop.

🎶 10. “Forever Like That” – Ben Rector

Bright, folksy, and uplifting, this is ideal for couples who want a first dance that feels effortless and joyful.

🕯️ Tips for Picking Your Perfect Song:

• Think about a song that tells your story—not someone else’s.

• Choose lyrics that feel honest and emotional, not just pretty.

• If you're torn, ask your DJ to make a short custom edit with your favorite verse and chorus.

• Don’t be afraid to go acoustic or find a unique cover of a song you love.

Final Thought:

Your first dance is your moment. It’s not about impressing the crowd—it’s about celebrating the connection only you and your partner share. Whether you go offbeat, indie, or just slightly under the radar, these first dance songs will keep your day feeling personal, fresh, and unforgettable.

💬 Did you find your first dance song on this list? Or do you have a hidden gem that more couples should hear? Drop it in the comments!

Want help curating your full wedding playlist? Let’s make some musical magic. 🎧💍